Dock Shelters vs Dock Seals

It may seem like a small issue, but each little gap you see around a parked trailer at the loading dock is costing you money.

The heating and air conditioning that escapes through these gaps can cost you hundreds of dollars per year, per dock position, and that’s just a start. Those gaps also allow unwanted outside elements like dust, wind, rain, bugs and rodents into your facility. This can easily contribute to product damage, cause issues with warehouse inspections and create an uncomfortable environment for your employees.

To combat these areas, Ulti Group provides a series of dock shelters and dock seals, to ensure that the only things going in and out of the loading dock doors are things that should be. While dock shelters and seals have the same goal of environmental control, they are uniquely designed to serve different applications. So knowing the differences between the two will help you make the right choice for your needs.

Dock Shelters

Dock Shelters are enclosures that seal the perimeter of the trailer to form a seal. This is accomplished by applying pressure against the sides of the trailer with fabric curtains fitted with fiberglass stays. They fit larger dock door openings and service a wide variety of trailer heights and styles while being subjected to less damage from daily wear and tear since they aren’t designed to be compressed into by the trailer. They also allow for full, unobstructed access to loads on the trailer for maximum loading and unloading efficiency.

As a category, dock shelters historically could not provide as tight of a seal as foam dock seals, but newer models are equipped with features that allow them to match the sealing effectiveness of foam seals. For example, some older or less expensive dock shelters leave trailer door hinge gaps unsealed, amounting to about 2.5 sq ft of open space at every dock position through which energy flows out and contaminants flow in. Additionally, many shelters have less-than-ideal sealing at the tops of trailers, and most leave large corner gaps when the trailer is backed in. Newer models, like the Eclipse® shelter, however, include side curtains with a hook on the edge that wraps around the hinge gap on each side of the trailer, allowing for a complete seal. Plus, trailer tops are more tightly sealed with weighted, gravity-based head curtains and corner gaps get plugged through engineered side curtain/head curtain functioning.

Dock Seals

Dock Seals are foam pads that the trailer compresses into when it backs in and comes to rest against the dock bumpers, forming a seal around three sides of the trailer. Generally, dock seals provide a tight seal for a relatively low price, but they can become worn easily at loading docks that receive heavy traffic. Dock seals are best used when there is a minor variation in the size and style of trailers being served.

Because of their design, foam compression dock seals can restrict forklift access to the trailer. This happens as foam and fabric from the dock seal side pads enter the trailer opening when they are compressed by the trailer. Dock seals, by design, however, typically take up less space on the outside of the dock, so if space is an issue, then this may be the route that makes sense.

Like dock shelters, some dock seals perform better than others. Top-of-the-line dock seals are built with special features that protect against specific sources of damage, including trailer pressure and friction, burns from trailer marker lights, as well as head pad sag and pop-off.

 

Dock Shelters vs. Dock Seals

Dock Shelters
Dock Seals

Price
Generally more expensive than dock seals, and price based on level of sealing effectiveness and durability
Generally lower priced than dock shelters, although top dock seal models can be more pricey than low-end shelters

Sealing Effectiveness
Depends on the model chosen. Some provide excellent sealing effectiveness, on par with the best compression dock seals. Others leave significant gaps. Types of trailers being served can also affect sealing effectiveness so selecting the right model is key.
Generally very good to excellent, depending on whether top is sealed with head curtain or head pad, and whether or not has added features.

Versatility
Able to fit larger dock door openings and service a wide variety of trailer heights and styles. Less subject to damage over time.
Good for applications where dock openings are relatively small; a variety of trailer sizes being serviced are limited, and/or space between door openings is tight.

Head Curtain
Higher-end models use weight and gravity to keep in contact with the roof of the trailer and automatically position on trailer top
Manual adjustment required

Durability

Less subject to damage from daily wear and tear

 

Prone to wear and tear, but these can be reduced by adding features like replaceable reinforcement boots and friction-resistant fabric

Conclusion

Ultimately, what’s important when choosing between a dock shelter or dock seal is determining the right solution that will help you to eliminate gaps at the dock in the most efficient way possible. Both options have their advantages and disadvantages.

We recommend talking with our trained professionals to analyse your loading dock to give you the individual recommendation based on your specs, needs and restrictions.

In the meantime, Ulti Group has provided information on the different types of Dock Shelters and Dock Seals that we offer to give you an idea of what you should be looking for.